10 Most Expensive Nickels You Should Start Hunting For 

10. 1912 5C (Proof) 

9. 1911 5C (Proof) 

8. 1910 5C (Proof) 

7. 1909 5C (Proof) 

6. 1908 5C (Proof) 

5. 1928-S 5C (Regular Strike) 

4. 1928-D 5C (Regular Strike) 

3. 1928 5C (Regular Strike) 

2. 1927-S 5C (Regular Strike) 

1. 1927-D 5C (Regular Strike)